All the evidence was already provided and refuted you but the default ■■■■■■ algorithm is to automatically reject and discredit with no basis anything that is not in line with their fake mythologies.
According to a study published in June 2017 by Ranajit Das, Paul Wexler, Mehdi Pirooznia, and Eran Elhaik in Frontiers in Genetics , “in a principle component analysis (PCA) [of DNA], the ancient Levantines clustered predominantly with modern-day Palestinians and Bedouins…”[162] Additionally, in a study published in August of the same year by Marc Haber et al. in The American Journal of Human Genetics , the authors concluded that “The overlap between the Bronze Age and present-day Levantines suggests a degree of genetic continuity in the region.”[163]
In 638 CE, the IslamicCaliphate extended its dominion to Jerusalem.[10] With the Arab conquest of the region, ■■■■ were allowed back into the city.[11] While the majority population of Jerusalem during the time of Arab conquest was Christian,[12] the majority of the Palestine population of about 300,000-400,000 inhabitants, was still ■■■■■■■[13][ citation needed ] In the aftermath the process of cultural Arabization and Islamization took place, combining immigration to Palestine with the adoption of Arabic language and conversion of the part of local population to Islam.[14]
All of which has been resoundingly discredited by over 30 recent genetic studies and all of recorded history.
Both the maternal and paternal studies show a direct lineage to ■■■■ from The Levant, the old Hebrew/Judean Kingdoms and regions were ■■■■ were either captured and taken to or fled to during the Diaspora.
Apparently you’re blissfully unaware of just how far ranging King Solomon’s kingdom was and how widely ■■■■ had spread due to the expansion of trade throughout Africa, Asia, and Southern/Eastern Europe.
All of recorded history and Science refutes the entire premise which was concocted to attempt to refute the claims of Ashkenazi Population’s Right of Return and Israel’s claim to Israel as their historical homeland.
Over 90% of living ■■■■ can trace their lineage genetically directly to King David and Or Aaron, Moses’ brother.
Either that or it’s feigned ignorance and lies used to justify your Hatred of ■■■■ and Israeli ■■■■ in particular.
Ah there is the automatic denial algorithm yet again.
Stay mad rabbi.
Nope, stop inventing claims rabbi.
So those are all converts then, thanks for admitting it rabbi.
Sure it does rabbi. That’s why I completely refuted your false mythologies just now with both historical accounts and genetic proof.
HAHAHAHAHAHAH
This is the best thing yet that discredits you… even better than anything I’ve posted infact.
So at the end of the day you have been entirely exposed as being a typical lying ■■■ inventing claims that even your own links don’t corroborate and you have been completely refuted by me using actually historical and genetic proof.
It must suck to be a seething ■■■ like you who can’t accept reality.
All of the linked studies and many more prove the myth is nothing but a lie traced directly to Nazis and Arabs trying to discredit the claims of of ■■■■ to their ■■■■■■ Homeland.
Either you’re just a liar or you didn’t bother reading even a single one of them.
DNA Studies
A variety of DNA studies over an extended period of time support the fact that Ashkenazic ■■■■ originated in the Middle East (also called the Near East). Some of these studies include the following:
Hammer, et al. conclude that the Y chromosome of most Ashkenazi and Sephardi ■■■■ contained mutations that are also common among Middle Eastern peoples, but uncommon in the general European population (source: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2000). This suggests that the male ancestors of the Ashkenazi ■■■■ could be traced mostly to the Middle East;
The proportion of male genetic admixture in Ashkenazi ■■■■ amounts to less than 0.5% per generation over an estimated 80 generations, with “relatively minor contribution of European Y chromosomes to the Ashkenazim,” according to Hammer et. al. (source: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2000);
Two studies by Nebel et al. in 2001 and 2005, based on Y chromosome polymorphic markers, suggest that Ashkenazi ■■■■ are more closely related to other ■■■■■■ and Middle Eastern groups than to their host populations in Europe – defined in the using Eastern European, German, and French Rhine Valley populations (source: European Journal of Human Genetics);
In 2004, Behar et al compared data from Ashkenazi groups in ten different European areas (France, Germany, the Netherlands; Austria-Hungary, Byelorussia, Lithuania, Poland, Romania, Russia, and Ukraine ) with data from non-■■■■■■ groups in seven different countries (France, Germany, Austria, Hungary, Poland, Romania, and Russia). They found that nine of the ■■■■■■ groups were similar, with low rates of admixture with non-■■■■■■ groups, but that these Ashkenazi groups were closely related to non-Ashkenazi ■■■■ and to some non-■■■■■■ Near Eastern groups (Human Genetics, 2004);
A 2006 study by Behar et al. based on high-resolution analysis of haplogroup K (mtDNA), suggested that about 40% of the current Ashkenazi population is descended matrilineally from just four women, or “founder lineages”, that were likely from a Hebrew/Levantine mtDNA pool originating in the Middle East in the 1st and 2nd centuries C.E. Behar et al. suggest that the rest of Ashkenazi mtDNA is originated from ~150 women, most of those likely of Middle Eastern origin. (source: American Journal of Human Genetics, 2006);
Medical studies of the DNA of various diaspora ■■■■■■ populations – from Iranian, Iraqi, Syrian, Italian, Turkish, Greek, and Ashkenazi – have shown them to all be close Middle Eastern kin (source: American Journal of Human Genetics, 2010); and
Ashkenazi Levites paternally descend from an Iranian people, not from Khazars or Slavs, according to genetic evidence revealed in a study by Siiri Rootsi et al. (Nature Communications, 2013).
Since no other paternal or maternal haplogroup among Ashkenazim comes from a Central Asian Turkic source either, there is a total absence of evidence for Khazar ancestry in Ashkenazi ■■■■■ Kevin Brook, who has been researching the possibility of Khazar ancestry for 20 years among Ashkenazim and wrote a book entitled “The ■■■■ of Khazaria”, concludes: “Surprisingly, there is evidence for small amounts of southern Chinese, Berber, and Slavic ancestry in Ashkenazi ■■■■■ but not for Turkic Khazar ancestry.”
Conclusion
Though Ashkenazim are the largest ethnic group of ■■■■ today, Sephardim and Mizrahim also consist of a significant part of the ■■■■■■ population, both in Israel and in the diaspora. Additionally, Israel has become the home of many smaller ■■■■■■ ethnic groups, such as Ethiopian ■■■■■ Yemenite ■■■■■ and Kaifeng ■■■■■
The Khazar hypothesis does not address these populations in Israel at all. Sephardim and Mizrahim have historic claims to Israel. Additionally, based on the above evidence, Ashkenazim also have historic claims to Israel. Moreover, the genetic studies above refute the claim that all Ashkenazic populations descend from Khazars.
The genetic studies above put the Khazar myth to rest. If you bump into the Khazar myth, make sure to refute it.
It originated with a Germanic/Hungarian born, Austrian Educated, communist Anti Semite who later lived in FR and the UK in the 1800’s and has been promoted by Nazis, Arabs, along with their enablers and sympathizers since in spite of it having no basis in fact.
Once again all of history and science refutes the “myth” completely and the source is easily identified as well as are those who continue to further the lie.
You are proving my point for me rabbi. First of all you are conveniently injecting your own opinion in there because no where does it say that ■■■■ come from the Levant, it says that they have an origin in the Middle East which is what I have been saying already, Ashkenazis originate from Iran from Iranian converts which is in the Middle East, not in the Levant.
Thank you for admitting it rabbi.
I never said anything about Khazars by the way, you’re the one who keeps bringing that up to use as a strawman argument, that’s how pathetic and desperate you are with your lies. Ashkenazis are originally Iranian converts who migrated to North Eastern Turkey along the silk road.
Again you are making a fool of yourself in this thread. ■■■■ don’t come from the Levant and nothing that you posted proves that ■■■■ come from the Levant. Meanwhile I already entirely refuted your BS and false ■■■■■■ mythologies with actual historical and genetic facts and even your own links it shows that at the closest, some ■■■■ are actually Iranian converts from Iran who migrated to North Eastern Turkey. Deal wit it rabbi.
In conclusion ■■■■ are nothing but liars. Thanks for proving that fact for me rabbi.
Khazar ■■■■ have nothing to do with the Levant.
Khazars are an Asian people like the Chinese, Korean and Japanese, who were defeated by the Chinese Tang Empire in the 7th century.
The Gokturks, who the Khazars are part of, fled west, conquering the vast steppes of Central Asia and crossed the Volga late 6th century.
As the Khazars felt they were abandoned their deities, they decided to change religion and identity in the 9th century.
Over the centuries, Khazars intermixed with slaves from Central Asia, Caucasus and eastern Europe.
Khazars have no identity. They are parasites. Their “■■■■■■■■■■■ is only a facade.
Which of course has zero to do with your completely refuted repeated too lie.
The Ashenazi can trace their lineage directly to Aaron by some 58% as you were shown in prior studies and over 90% directly to the House of David.
One more time.
Now stop lying and deflecting, you have absolutely nothing to stand on.
Both the Paternal and Maternal DNA show your lies to be exactly that, lies told with the intent to challenge the ■■■■■■ claims to Israel as their ancestral homeland.
It is completely irrefutable and based solely on solid proven science so quit.
The Pilpul is strong with this rabbi. All the historical and genetic proof provided by me and even your own links make it clear that modern-day ■■■■ don’t originate from within that red boundary of the Levant. Learn to accept reality Moshe, I know it’s hard for ■■■■ to do that but at least try.
LOL, again discrediting yourself and exposing your delusions in the thread.
Reminder that the truth is always the opposite of what ■■■■ say.
The truth is what you cant’ stand or refute so you attack me personally.
Based on the DNA of today’s Kohanim, the geneticists have dated their “Most Common Recent Ancestor” to 106 generations ago, approximately 3,300 years before the present. This is in agreement with the Torah’s written and oral tradition of the lifetime of Aaron, the original High Priest and founder of the Kohen lineage. Further genetic studies have found that the CMH-the Cohen Modal Haplotype-a haplotype of the MED (J) haplogroup-is not exclusive to Kohanim, and not unique to ■■■■■ It is also found in significant percentages among other Middle Eastern populations, and to a lesser extent, among southern Mediterranean groups. A haplotype is a group of distinct DNA markers – neutral nucleotide mutations, which when found together indicate a lineage. These particular markers were discovered on the Y-Chromosome, which is passed from father to son, without change, thus establishing a paternal lineage pattern.
The links to the studies are included.
Why keep lying? What is it you have to gain?
As for your map, apparently you need a basic lesson in map reading along with someone to show you how to read your own graph that you posted showing about 80% or greater linkage proven between the Ashkenazim and Levant.
Cool story Rabbi, so they have a common ancestor from 3,300 years ago originating in Iran. Still not from the Levant.
Also “Aish.com” is not a credible source. Nice try though.
Ok this is going to be fun. Provide the original source to the paps in the post above as well as to those you posted above, graph and map, all of which specifically relate to Askenazi ■■■■ but you didn’t bother to read them.
Then the real fun begins.
Of course you’ll try to claim the article I cited has no credibility which is why I pointed out the embedded links to the original source material used.
I suppose Stamford is in on the conspiracy as well too… . So must then be the authors of the thirty other plus studies that refute completely everything you have claimed.
Good information in the OP video. There is really nothing more to say. Palestinians are like populations made up of people from the other Arab states. Maybe they were rejects that were pushed out of their native countries.
Doesn’t matter, literally nothing you posted showed evidence of modern-day ■■■■ being from Palestine meanwhile I have already proven both historically and genetically that modern-day ■■■■ don’t come from Palestine while Palestinians are the indigenous population going back over 5000 years in Palestine. At the most Ashkenazi ■■■■ originate from Iranian converts.
